
Sarah Martin on scrutinising One Nation and rebuilding trust in journalism
Australian newsrooms were slow to subject One Nation to sustained scrutiny, Guardian Australia investigations correspondent Sarah Martin told a Reddit Ask Me Anything. Asked why the party had escaped the level of investigation directed at similar movements overseas, Martin said coverage had since improved, although she believed vested interests still clouded the judgment of some media organisations. Martin, who has reported on Pauline Hanson and Gina Rinehart through written investigations and the podcasts The Populist and Gina, argued that the party deserved the same scrutiny as its competitors.
Asked whether her reporting would damage One Nation politically, Martin declined to predict the outcome. The journalist’s role was to put verified information before the public and let readers decide what to make of it, she said. She argued that the uncertainty about how voters might respond was no reason to ease scrutiny.
On why One Nation was gaining momentum, Martin pointed to economic hardship, inequality, unease about migration levels and frustration with the major parties. She said social media algorithms that reward division and misinformation also created favourable conditions for populist politics, and highlighted pollster Kos Samaras’s research into what was motivating One Nation voters.
A reader asked whether reluctance to discuss immigration’s drawbacks had helped One Nation attract support. Martin agreed that avoiding the subject could fuel mistrust among people with concerns about migration levels. She called for a less political discussion of immigration policy’s successes and failures and recommended the work of British labour economist Alan Manning, whom the team interviewed for The Populist.
Asked about Victoria’s election, Martin said journalists should be cautious about making predictions. She noted that Barnaby Joyce had played down One Nation’s prospects and that Hanson had been largely absent from campaigning. She also cautioned that the party had previously exceeded expectations in South Australia. At the time of the AMA, she thought polling pointed most strongly to a Liberal majority, with preferences potentially decisive in a handful of seats.
The same reader asked for her view of South Australian premier Peter Malinauskas. Martin recalled knowing him from her time covering state politics, going back to his days in the shop assistants’ union. She described him as a master of populism.
Asked what people already familiar with her investigations might have overlooked, Martin said the depth and reach of Rinehart’s influence in Australian public life remained crucial to understanding the story. She believed there were many more stories to tell and hoped to report some of them.
On whether there was evidence that Rinehart or One Nation had funded Karl Stefanovic’s show, Martin said there was none. She said she had explored the question and raised a broader concern about the limited transparency surrounding some podcasts. In her view, existing disclosure requirements might fail to capture a financial contribution to a privately operated show.
Asked about Rinehart’s reported investments in medicinal cannabis and whether she had lobbied for legalisation, Martin said she had not examined the investments closely. She was unaware of any such lobbying and suggested the holdings might be relatively small within Rinehart’s broader investments.
On One Nation excluding news organisations, Martin called the practice undemocratic and said it suggested an unwillingness to face difficult questions. Asked whether it could be stopped, she argued that it would take a stronger response from media organisations collectively.
A separate reader asked why other outlets had shown little concern about those exclusions. Martin said the response had disappointed her and called for more solidarity across the Australian media industry.
Asked whether access to politicians had changed after the attack on independent MP Helen Haines, Martin said she had noticed no difference. She qualified her answer by noting that she no longer worked on the daily politics beat, and said politicians generally remained willing to engage with journalists.
A reader asked how she could fairly report on people her audience disliked and whether she was tempted to cater to readers’ views. Martin said the facts should determine the reporting. She pointed to sympathetic observations about Rinehart included in Gina and argued that tailoring an investigation to satisfy an audience at the expense of accuracy would undermine a journalist’s credibility.
On choosing investigations when politicians on opposing sides might have similar vulnerabilities, Martin said reporters needed to watch for hypocrisy and areas where parties avoided scrutinising each other. She cited grant programs as an example of subjects MPs might hesitate to criticise because doing so could expose their own side to examination.
Challenged about accusations of ideological activism at the Guardian, Martin defended its record of independent journalism and said reader support had allowed her to report freely. She saw no conflict between the organisation’s values and investigating Rinehart’s influence or Hanson’s party. Accusations of activism did not trouble her, she said.
Asked whether a publisher had ever pushed her towards a political narrative, Martin recalled being discouraged from writing stories critical of a particular politician while she was political editor at the West Australian. She said she had resisted unsuccessfully. She left the politician and the circumstances unidentified.
On whether reporters’ personal views differed from what their employers published, Martin said they often did. She described many journalists working for Rupert Murdoch’s outlets as capable reporters whose views could differ from those of their editors. Responding to the reader’s further question about confronting extremism, she said she tried to challenge it in her work and daily life.
Asked how journalists verify information and what AI might change, Martin said seeking primary sources was more important than ever. The fundamentals of checking facts and verifying sources remained the same, she argued, although AI would demand more technical knowledge and diligence.
On her own use of AI, Martin said she generally tried to avoid it. Occasionally, she used it to help locate a primary source when she had lost an original reference. Reading The Nerd Reich had made her more inclined to opt out altogether, she said.
Asked about disinformation campaigns and foreign technology companies’ influence on Australian politics, Martin called for greater urgency from both politicians and newsrooms. She said much more work was needed to understand and address that influence.
Another reader asked whether misinformation on social media had made her job harder. Martin agreed it had, while saying she sometimes saw her reporting reach audiences through Facebook. That gave her some hope that verified journalism could still reach people who might otherwise dismiss it.
On declining trust in mainstream media since Covid, Martin pointed to more time spent online, the spread of misinformation and a wider loss of confidence in institutions. She also suggested journalists might have failed to scrutinise some government decisions adequately during the pandemic, when they were covering an unprecedented event that affected their own lives.
Asked whether journalism had deteriorated over the past two decades, Martin said repeated newsroom redundancies had weakened an industry transformed by the internet. Detailed reporting required time and resources, she said, while some outlets’ efforts to win attention by becoming louder had further damaged the quality of coverage.
Asked what readers should look for in good journalism, Martin pointed to deep research, strong sources and verified facts. She emphasised information over opinion and evidence over personality.
On whether more detailed reporting would regain ground from lightweight lifestyle content, Martin said much depended on what audiences chose to read and value. She hoped it would.
The questions were sourced from the general public through an online Q&A on the Australian community of Reddit (AMA): https://www.reddit.com/r/australian/comments/1xx9euv/ama_im_sarah_martin_senior_investigations/
We hope you enjoyed this article. To read all our business articles, please click here.
Please check out our online shop where you can buy all our Doctor Who and Star Trek books as paperbacks or eBooks.

I hate to ask, but I need your help. For some time now, I have been bringing you video Q&A sessions with politicians and political commentators, as well as my own news and political commentary. However, the production costs are considerable, so I am asking if you can donate a small amount to assist. Click below to read more.

Follow us on Social Media

Leave a Reply